Edmonton Police Service is continuing the controversial practice of street checking or “carding”, despite being accused of racism from groups in Edmonton. Black Lives Matter along with Indigenous groups are calling for a ban on carding when police do random spot checks on individuals and collect their personal information. They say too often Indigenous and black people are targeted. They are calling for the Edmonton Police Service to scrap the program by the end of the year.
“Street checks are the process of arbitrarily stopping and collecting information from individuals who are not suspected of committing a crime.” says Bashir Mohamed from Black Lives Matter Edmonton. They requested data about who Edmonton Police are stopping. They found Indigenous individuals are 4 times more likely to be stopped than their white counterparts. Indigenous women face the highest rates at 6.5 times than the number of white women checked, and black Edmontonians are 3.6 times more likely to be carded than white Edmontonians.
Edmonton police conduct about 26,000 of these checks per year. Many are simply situations where officers ask people how they are doing. In some cases officers collect personal identifications. The practice is based on criminal profiling, not racial profiling, the police stress. Talking to the community is critical to the EPS’ work. All officers are trained on racial vs criminal profiling. Loosing the ability to conduct street checks would compromise the ability for officers to do their jobs, police argue.
“As much as community-based policing model is in our DNA, I would almost say or suggest that we move to a relationship-based policing model, where relationships with the community are important on all levels.” said Insp. Dan Jones, EPS Investigative Supports Branch, “whether that be our youth, our business owners, our vulnerable population, or our criminally involved.”
“We’re continuing to see the number in our street checks decline.” says EPS. In 2016, the Edmonton Police put in place a new street check policy. They say these numbers don’t tell the whole story, and they may be misrepresented geographically like in downtown problem areas. “We’re not just randomly arbitrarily stopping people. That were doing it in those areas that we’ve identified to have issues with crime.” Some community groups are defending the practice. “Had they not checked on me, I probably could have been dead a few times, you know, because there was times where I needed them to check on me” said Theresa Strong, a former gang member. “I needed to go to jail for the night and sleep for the night or something because I was so addicted.”
It’s a controversial practice across Canada, with Ontario banning random carding at the start of this year. But critics say the rules don’t go far enough, some saying officers can still gather private and sensitive information if they say they are probing a crime. Last week, a Lethbridge, Alberta lawyer also called for the checks to be stopped. The province’s Justice Minister has already formed a group to review police checks. Kathleen Ganley says “consulting with Albertans is the next step in determining if changes are needed or should they be stopped all together.”
She went on to say “Community based policing can build trust and relationships that prevent criminal activity and keep communities safe. Police are expected to use this tool in accordance with Alberta’s Provincial Policing Standards, which indicates policing must be impartial to all persons and service must be provided without regard to race or ethnic origin. I and my office have been in contact with Edmonton Police Chief; Rod Kencht, and I understand the EPS has been examining their practices regarding street checks, including having reached out to the Alberta Human Rights Commission to ensure they are following best practices. Although we have not received any formal or specific complaints related to street checks, my office has been in contact with the Alberta Human Rights Commission to ensure that policing practices respect the diversity of this province. We will continue to seek guidance from the Commission.”
This article was written by Stacey Leochko.
428
VIEWS
92
SHARES
55
COMMENTS
As far as I understand it if your not driving a vehicle or being detained this is illegal
I did not know that.
All Cops think you are guilty until proven innocent
Also add one to the list, if you break a driving infraction on a bicycle if you don’t have ID you have to provide your legitimate name or you can get charged with obstructing justice.
Questioning is not illegal and as far this whole thing goes sounds like someone is trolling for bigots …, Fact Canadian jails have only 25% are First Nations……Fact 90% of all crimes in the city of Edmonton Happen in the downtown core, so if the police are not allowed to talk to people in this area…… color or race are not the problem people trying to lay blame somewhere else is
Um if a cop walks up to you in the street you don’t have to say a God dam thing to then nor do you have to provide them with any identification
They are allowed to ask… But you aren’t required to produce except for what’s.mentioned above
Black Lives Mater?
I noticed that too.
Wasnt the only error either. Hm
All lives matter
Neil i was actually only making a comment on their incorrect spelling of “matter”, but thanks for your groundbreaking input
YES! Black Lives Do Matter!!
If you haven’t done anything why are you worried?
its harassment and wrong if they single out one race
If you haven’t done anything, why is it their business?
And it’s comments like that this that make you part of the problem and not part of the solution. So in this same respect it’s alright to let them into your home if you haven’t done anything wrong and don’t need a warrant! Bet you have the same outlook on your privacy too eh? Sure invade my privacy as I haven’t done anything wrong…lol SMH no wonder why we are decades behind other first world nations when it comes to policy!
This is so ridiculous. Everything is racial these days to people. They do these street checks in areas of higher crime like downtown and just outside downtown where the population is higher if the races being so offended. Like already me tiobed here if you didn’t do a trying wrong then what’s the big deal. They have every right to ask people for id because it is actually illegal to be over the age of 18 a d not carry Id. $250 fine.
your white privilege is showing
“everything is racial these days to people”…
Canada as we know it today was built on racism and to this day is a huge problem, hence why a lot of issues stem from racism and will continue to be an issue until the problem is solved.
My white privilege??? My race is half of other than Caucasian. I’m not at all racist but I’m not going to pull a race card if I get id’ d by the cops! They are doing their jobs!
Kim Downs no public safety is the issue . Stop me and ask for my I’d all you want . Why in the hell would that offend anyone . Was asked plenty for it when we were teens in the wrong places
Okay Nicole, I’m calling in that. Please show me in the criminal code where it says that it’s illegal to be over the age of 18 and NOT carry ID
so carding every black person they see inatead of every white person is ok?? the numbers dont lie
Maura O’Donoghue-Wiull when they are harrasing one race over the other based on race then yes thats the issue
Kim Downs well hate to say it but the areas they are carding may have more from certain races no ?
And I’m not trying to be a whitey not getting it , but they are doing this on areas where we have high transiency rates and we know certain groups are at a disadvantage
I had a friend that was actually issued a fine when she couldn’t produce her id when asked.
O’Donoghue-WiullMaura I agree totally.
If they are transients on the street check them period yellow, black white red or purple!
it not just transient people who this is happening to.
Boo fucking who!!! Fucking weak people
good timing considering how many indigenous people around the world are going to be in this city and province for the World Indigenous Games. What kind of impression are they going to get when they get stopped by the police “just to check” individuals. I had out of town visitors get carded and one even get a ticket for loitering just because they were sitting and watching the festivals that were happening on Whyte ave. Funny how they have never come back and spent money in this city after that.
You can say no thanks and walk away. No problem.
No you can not just walk away from a police officer or else you would be arrest!!
You don’t have to provide ID if no laws have been broken. Is that not the case? I have refused before and the officer agreed it was optional.
Good to know!
Very uplifting.
How do you prove this? Unless you are present for an officers entire shift and keep count of everyone he requests identification from. Show your ID and stop looking for a reason to whine and complain. People should stop spreading “laws” based on the crap someone told them on the interwebs. Too many people take it as truth and then go try to form a one man protest based on stupidity.
If you have nothing to hide and have done nothing wrong, then just show your I.d. Or dont and move along.
Its not rocket science
Always a “nothing to hide” in the crowd. smh
I for one believe in standing up for m rights.
Well if you have nothing to worry about, why are you getting so anxious about it?
But Gary they only said they were doing it for my safety…. why am I now living in a police state….
Nobody said you had to give your I.d. Or did you miss the part of it being optional??
Seriously? You honestly have no idea what you are talking about Kitty. If you fully read the article, it stated that it cards indigenous and blacks more times than white individuals. Which is wrong and racial profiling. Also, no police office should stop Anyone regardless what race that person is.I guess you would not know what racial profiling is because your white privilege!!
“Nothing to hide” is a cop out for people not willing to stand up for their rights. By showing ID when I don’t need to I’m encouraging cops to breach my rights and the rights of others. Not going to do it.
Be polite and respectful. The good cops will be fine with that. The bad ones not so much.
Gary could you bend over a moment here while I check a certain cavity… we are only checking for rabid ferrets!!! We know you likely not to be hiding any but for yours and the public’s safety we have to check.
And you’re allowed to say no to the request as was previously stated. Ive been stopped by the cops on numerous occasions, I just answer their questions and move on
Kitty Red Sylver … The fact police are asking in the first place is what bothers me. Most people don’t know and simply comply because they’re asked and are unknowingly giving up their rights.
What if I told you that you don’t have to show ID to a police officer unless you’ve either been arrested or are operating a motor vehicle?
Since I was a teenager and travelling around Edmonton on the bus to the Library and various events at Churchill square, I was told that I had to carry ID and show it to a police officer if approached and asked to prove I was not a vagrant. That I had a home address. Seemed reasonable. I’ve never been asked but there are a million people in town so just figured it was due to the randomness of the checks.
I’m not sure if I would ever be offended if asked to show ID. If you are not doing anything wrong why be offended?
Safety and protection first … who gives a shit what race you are….pretty sure the OTHER race get Id too .. police are doing their job !
Wonder why lol
If your a law abiding legal citizen who isn’t a piece of garbage this shouldn’t be an issue
My teenaged white privileged daughter was pulled over on our range road last week by the police she was doing 40 km/hr coming home from work….. reason they pulled her over??? Multiple attempted B & E in the area… we didnt go on social media screaming discrimination or racism. The police were doing their job keeping our neighborhood safe.
I think the saying should be “ALL LIVES MATTER”